Skip to main content

How to Check Your Payslip Is Correct When Working Through SmartWork

 

In brief

  • Use Payslip Buddy (free with SmartWork) for a line-by-line report on your payslip.
  • Use the Payslip Buddy calculator or HMRC’s umbrella company calculator to estimate your take-home pay from your assignment rate.
  • Use HMRC’s PAYE Tax Calculator to check your income tax, using your gross pay, not your assignment rate.
  • Check your year-to-date figures against what HMRC holds in your Personal Tax Account.
  • If something doesn’t look right, contact us, and we’ll look into it.

Introduction

When you work through an umbrella company, it’s important to understand your payslip and be confident you’re being paid correctly. At SmartWork, we want you to see clearly how your pay is calculated, what’s deducted, and how your take-home pay is worked out.

This guide covers four ways to check your payslip, shows a worked example comparing a SmartWork payslip with Payslip Buddy and HMRC, and explains what to do if something doesn’t look right.

1. Use Payslip Buddy (free with SmartWork)

Payslip Buddy is free for SmartWork contractors. It checks your payslip and produces a report explaining how your pay was calculated.

Every line explained. Your report covers, in plain English:

  • Tax code and income tax
  • Employee National Insurance
  • Employer National Insurance
  • Umbrella company margin
  • Apprenticeship Levy, where applicable
  • Gross pay and net take-home pay
  • Holiday pay and other payments or deductions

This shows how your assignment rate is broken down and how your take-home pay is reached.

Email notification and dashboard. When your report is ready, we’ll email you. Log in to your SmartWork dashboard to view and download it as a PDF.

Yours to keep. Previous reports stay in your dashboard, so you can keep a record of your payslip checks.

2. Use the Payslip Buddy online calculator

You can also use Payslip Buddy’s free calculator to estimate your take-home pay. Enter your assignment rate and pay details to see an estimated breakdown of gross pay, deductions and take-home pay, then compare it with your payslip.

3. Use HMRC’s umbrella company calculator

HMRC provides an official calculator to help you work out how your pay should be calculated when you work through an umbrella company. Enter your assignment details to see an estimated breakdown, then compare it with your payslip.

4. Worked example: SmartWork, Payslip Buddy and HMRC

Assumptions. This example uses a standard tax code (1257L), National Insurance category A, weekly pay and rolled-up holiday pay, with no pension contributions, student loan or expenses. Your own figures will differ if your circumstances differ.

A contractor on a day rate of £350, working five days a week:

Description  Amount 
Daily assignment rate  £350.00 
Days worked per week  5 
Weekly assignment value  £1,750.00 

How the results compare:

  SmartWork payslip  Payslip Buddy  HMRC estimate 
Gross weekly pay  £1,510.31  £1,510.30  £1,510.31 
Net weekly pay  £1,079.24  £1,079.00  £1,079.08 

The three net pay figures are within 24p of each other: 

  • SmartWork and HMRC: 16p 
  • SmartWork and Payslip Buddy: 24p 
  • HMRC and Payslip Buddy: 8p 

Differences of a penny or so in individual lines come from rounding. For example, employer National Insurance is £212.15 in Payslip Buddy and £212.14 in HMRC. 

Payslip Buddy breakdown 

Step 1: From assignment rate to gross pay

Description  Amount 
Weekly assignment rate  £1,750.00 
Employer National Insurance  £212.15 
Apprenticeship Levy  £7.55 
Umbrella company margin  £20.00 
Total employment costs  £239.70 
Gross pay  £1,510.30 

Step 2: From gross pay to net pay 

Description  Amount 
Basic pay  £1,347.64 
Rolled-up holiday pay  £162.66 
Gross pay  £1,510.30 
Income tax  £362.43 
Employee National Insurance  £68.87 
Net take-home pay  £1,079.00 

Payslip Buddy also explains your tax code, National Insurance category, personal allowance and taxable income. 

HMRC breakdown 

Description  Amount 
Assignment rate  £1,750.00 
Umbrella company margin  £20.00 
Employer National Insurance  £212.14 
Apprenticeship Levy  £7.55 
Gross pay (including £162.66 rolled-up holiday pay)  £1,510.31 
Employee income tax  £362.36 
Employee National Insurance  £68.87 
Net take-home pay  £1,079.08 

What this shows. The three calculations are consistent, with only a very small difference in take-home pay. Calculators give estimates, while your payslip reflects your actual payroll calculation, so small differences are normal.

To see what this calculation looks like on a SmartWork sample payslip, click here.

5. Check your PAYE income tax

You can check the income tax deducted from your pay using HMRC’s PAYE Tax Calculator.

You’ll need three details from your payslip:

  • Gross taxable pay: your gross pay figure, not your assignment rate.
  • Tax code: the code shown on your payslip.
  • Pay date: the date you were paid.

Compare the estimated income tax with the PAYE deduction on your payslip. If they match, or are very close, that’s a useful sign your tax has been calculated correctly.

If the figures differ, check that you entered the right gross pay, tax code and pay date. Also consider your tax code basis:

  • Cumulative: the tax on each payslip depends on your pay and tax earlier in the tax year, so a single-payment calculation may not match unless that history is taken into account.
  • Week 1/Month 1: each payslip is calculated on its own, so a match is more likely.

Important: your assignment rate is not your gross taxable pay. Employer costs and the umbrella company margin are deducted from the assignment rate before your gross pay is calculated, so always use the gross pay figure from your payslip.

6. Check your year-to-date (YTD) earnings and tax

Checking each payslip matters, but so do your cumulative figures. Your YTD figures show what you’ve earned and how much income tax has been deducted since the start of the tax year on 6 April. This is especially important if you’ve changed assignments or umbrella companies, or had more than one job in the tax year.

What to check on your payslip

  • Taxable pay to date: your total taxable earnings so far this tax year.
  • Income tax paid to date: the total PAYE tax deducted so far.
  • Tax code: is it correct for your circumstances?
  • Previous employment: has any earlier pay and tax this tax year been taken into account?

Check what HMRC holds

You can see the employment and PAYE information HMRC holds about you through your Personal Tax Account or the HMRC app: HMRC – Check your Income Tax for the current year

Compare it with the YTD figures on your SmartWork payslips. HMRC’s records are based on information employers report through payroll, so allow for reporting delays and check that your latest payment has been included.

Why this matters. If you’re on a cumulative tax code, your tax is calculated using your earnings and tax earlier in the tax year. If earlier employment details are missing or wrong, you could pay too much or too little tax.

If you notice missing employment information, unexpected YTD figures or a tax code that looks wrong, contact SmartWork and check your records with HMRC.

7. Payslip checklist

  • Tax code: correct for your circumstances?
  • Gross pay: does it reflect your assignment rate after employer costs and the margin?
  • Employer costs: employer National Insurance and the Apprenticeship Levy are deducted before gross pay is calculated.
  • Umbrella margin: is the agreed margin applied?
  • Holiday pay: is it shown, and is it included in your gross pay?
  • Income tax and employee National Insurance: do they look right for your tax code and earnings?
  • YTD figures: do they match your records and what HMRC shows?
  • Net pay: does the amount paid to you match your payslip?

8. If something doesn’t look right

Small differences between your payslip and a calculator are common. The usual causes are:

  • Rounding
  • A different tax code basis (cumulative vs Week 1/Month 1)
  • Differences in the information entered, such as pay period, pension or student loan
  • Earlier employment details not yet reflected in your records

If the difference is larger than you’d expect, or you can’t explain it, contact the SmartWork team. To help us look into it quickly, please include:

  • Your payslip and the pay period it covers
  • Your tax code
  • A screenshot or copy of the calculator result you’re comparing it with

You can also read the official guidance: Check your payslip is correct if you work through an umbrella company – GOV.UK

Understand your pay with confidence

Checking your payslip regularly is a simple way to stay informed. SmartWork gives you free access to Payslip Buddy, so you have an extra way to check your pay and keep a record of your reports. Whichever tools you use, our team is here to help if you have questions.